
SCREAM for your LIFE !!!
a.k.a. The Revenge Of The Blind Spot!
a.k.a. The Attack Of The Expanded BrainScreens!
An Investigation Of Cinematic Space, Of Sound And Image, Body And Screen and the Safety Of The Viewer in William Castle’s The Tingler
Introduction – The Tingler Is Loose In This Theatre
I am William Castle, the director of the motion picture you are about to see. I feel obligated to warn you that some of the sensations, some of the physical reactions which the actors on the screen will feel will also be experienced for the first time in motion picture history by certain members of this audience.[1]
- William Castle, from his introduction to The Tingler (1959)
Let me set the scene for you. It is the summer of 1959 and we are sitting in one of many cinemas in the U.S. showing William Castle’s latest feature. The film is called The Tingler and stars Vincent Price as a scientist bent on discovering the “force” that can appear and disappear in human beings during states of extreme fear.[2] Being familiar with Castle’s work we are expecting some sort of “gimmick” from this Master of Entertainment – William Castle has already produced such films as The House On Haunted Hill (1959) with the famous “Emergo” technique (inflatable skeletons flying over the audience) and The Macabre (1958) where audience members got fright insurance policies from Lloyd’s of London before viewing. The film starts with an introduction from Castle himself, cited above, warning us that we might experience some of the sensations portrayed on screen and advising us that if we would happen to feel a tingling sensation we must scream in order to release it – in fact, “a scream at the right time may save your life.”[3]
So the film begins and we fast-forward towards the famous “scream!” scene where we see an audience watching an old silent film – Tol’able David (1921) – and the monstrous Tingler breaks loose into the theatre. Suddenly the narrative stops and all we can see is a black screen as we hear the voice of Vincent Price addressing the audience: “Scream for your lives! The tingler is loose in this theatre!” Then audience members start screaming on the soundtrack – “It’s here! It’s over here! Help! Help! Look out, it’s under the seat!” – and as for us, the viewers in Anytown, USA, in the summer of 1959, everyone begins to scream in our theatre aswell because during that scene the projectionist has clear instructions to fire up the “Percept-o” – William Castle’s latest film gimmick. Suddenly one in every ten seats becomes electric and selected audience members get a buzz in their behinds, literally jumping out of their seats. In total darkness there is nothing but screams and panic until Vincent Price’s voice comes back on to soothe us: “The Tingler has been paralyzed by your screaming. There is no more danger. We will now resume the showing of the movie,” and the film narrative continues from the moment it was interrupted by this experimental manifestation of the on-screen monster in the outside reality of the cinema. This infamous “scream!” scene will be the focal point of my discussion of The Tingler.[4]
In the first half I would like to begin by looking at Žižek’s writing on the Blind Spot in connection to The Real and how it becomes apparant – even literal – in Castle’s film. I intend to describe the Blind Spot’s movement outside of it’s normal place and into The Real of the horror film, following it until the blind spot actually projects itself onto the silver screen – literally speaking. Then I will discuss Žižek’s idea of the Blind Spot of the visual manifested as sound and particularly focus on the idea of “the silent scream” in connection with the death of one of the film’s main characters.
In the second half I will touch on the subject of expanded cinema, as practiced by the Viennese actionists in the late 1960s, in connection to William Castle’s own experiments in the systematic breaking down of the relationship between spectator and screen. I will finish by writing about the idea of the brain as the screen and bodily experience of The Tingler with special emphasis on the viewer’s safety when visual distance can no longer protect you from the images on screen. Finally I want to discuss the experience of watching The Tingler in our present day and pose a question regarding the film’s place in contemporary film theory and whether or not it is possible for viewers today to experience it in the same way as people did in Anytown, USA back in 1959 when William Castle actually “buzzed 20,000,000 behinds.”[5]
Part One – The Revenge Of The Blind Spot
I
One single Anne Frank moves us more than the countless others who have suffered just as she did but whose faces have remained in the shadows. Perhaps it is better that way; if we were capable of taking in all the suffering of all those people, we would not be able to live.[6]
- Primo Levi, writer and Holocaust survivor
In his article “I Hear You With My Eyes” Slavoj Žižek works on the concept of “the gaze” from a Lacanian perspective and defines it in relation to Lacan’s theory of the objet petit a – the part that is excluded from our perception of reality in order for us to have “normal access” to the world that surrounds us. In the beginning of the article he refers to the uncanny sense that the object of our eye’s look is somehow looking back at us – and argues that the object returning our gaze is “a kind of empty a priori, [...] a kind of formal “condition of possibility” of our seeing anything at all.”[7] In other words, reality as a whole is too much for us to handle – we must reclaim sense and meaning and create an identity from what surrounds us through the gaze. We must make sense of our experiences of reality by carving our own field of perception and thereby creating a “Blind Spot” – objet petit a – in our vision of reality. Žižek further writes that in psychosis the object is included in reality which inevitably results in “the loss of reality”.[8] This particular feeling of the overwhelming reality that is beyond our control is well expressed in the above quote from writer Primo Levi about the power of the story of Anne Frank. It is a way of limiting our perception of what happened during the Holocaust and it is necessary for us to carve this story out of the whole reality in order to make sense of the experience in a meaningful way – otherwise the perception would be too great and our experience of reality would disintegrate.
But the Holocaust did happen and it wasn’t only Anne Frank who was a part of it. Real life surrounds us all the time – it is everything that we can not control – it is what Žižek refers to as “The Real”. It is the darker side of reality – when nothing makes sense, where there is no linearity, sequence or apparant meaning – and thus it is our role to create meaning, which we do through creating the Blind Spot in our perception of reality. This can be connected to the filmic experience as cinematic representations always include more than we can possibly perceive, leaving us with the need to create our own identity in this way. But what if the boundaries of The Real become uncertain and the horror of the Blind Spot tries to get back into our world, like some unnameable ancient force in an H.P. Lovecraft story? Herein lies the fascination with horror films. They connect us to the senselessness (in the multiple meanings of the word) of our surroundings – where everything and anything can collapse and Lacan’s objet petit a can make its appearance to confuse or frighten the spectator and show him what it is like to have The Real within his own carved vision of the world. Horror films revolve a lot around the idea of a power of life that can’t be controlled – of monsters, creatures or maniacs, that can not be killed by conventional methods – of this particular loss of reality control. In this aspect The Tingler is no exception.
II
To break the laws of nature is always a dangerous thing and we’ve not only broken laws, we’ve violated some basic principles. We had to, but now we’re gonna stop.[9]
– Dr. Warren Chapin, The Tingler
In his investigation into the element of fear doctor Warren Chapin (Vincent Price) discovers the existence of a creature that manifests in a person’s spine in states of extreme fear which he dubs “The Tingler”. It is an insect-like creature that has enough strength to easily shatter the spine but can be contained – or repressed – by the simple act of screaming when one is frightened. So the question is posed: what happens if a person doesn’t repress his or her fear and lets the Tingler grow? Will it eventually kill them – death by fear? – and if so, can the Tingler itself be contained and studied? Thus dr. Chapin sets out on a mission to get a live example of the beast in order to study it and further understand its function in relation to the human body:[10]
An X-Ray depicting The Tingler manifesting along a spinal cord.
To make a long story short the good doctor finally gets a live example when a deaf and dumb woman is scared to death – because she can not scream – and he gets to perform an autopsy on her. He successfully removes the Tingler from inside the body and brings it into the outside world. According to Žižek’s definition of the Blind Spot and The Real it becomes quite obvious that here we are dealing with an extreme version of that theory – in fact, we move towards an allegory of the fascination with horror films.
It is quite possible – and in fact quite easy – to read The Tingler as a conventional horror film that mixes The Real with “normal reality” through its use of a monster that can not be subdued by conventional methods (screaming is the only way to immobilize it) and, seemingly, can not be killed at all once it has been removed from its host. When the Tingler attacks dr. Chapin’s hand he likenes it to being stuck in an hydrolic press and describes it as having “tremendous power”:[11]
Look at that Tingler Dave, it’s an ugly and dangerous thing. Ugly because it’s the creation of man’s fear, which is ugly too. Dangerous because a frightened man is dangerous. We can’t destroy it, because we’ve removed it from its natural place! [12]
Read in this way, The Tingler is an example of an artwork that makes the viewer aware of The Real and creates a struggle between his own carved world vision and this confusing “new reality”. But there is an added dimension to the Tingler’s purpose. The fact that the Tingler is not only an object that causes fear to the spectator vis-à-vis the intrusion of the Real within our world, but is also the physical and biological manifestation of that fear makes way for a symbolic reading in which the Tingler itself can become a metaphor for Žižek’s Blind Spot.
First of all the Tingler is hidden – it is unseen. No one has known about its existence until dr. Chapin discovers it and no human being is ever aware that this organism resides inside their bodies. It is extra-terrestrial to us, it is not a part of our biological selves. Nevertheless it is created by us when we feel threatened – it is in fact our own fear manifested.[13] And in order for us to survive this threat we have to repress it – we scream so that we can ignore the fear and make it go away. We carve our own field of perception so that we can keep the Blind Spot blind – so that we can keep the Tingler hidden inside, where it is supposed to stay. The two above quotes from dr. Chapin are taken from the scene where he realizes the consequences of his experiments – that he has broken the laws of nature and violated some basic principles – and he sets out to make things right and get rid of the Tingler the only way he can: by putting it back inside the original host body, thereby rectifying his mistake. The only way to destroy the Tingler – and therefore create balance again for our “normal access to reality” – is to create another Blind Spot (or put the Blind Spot back where it belongs). Eventually, this is what happens in the film and the threat is – well, not really destroyed, but rather repressed once again and the illusion of safety is returned to the viewer. But before that happens something very interesting takes place which makes The Tingler all the more allegorical for the role of the Blind Spot in cinematic “reality”.
It concerns the infamous “scream!” scene described earlier, where the Tingler is loose inside the on-screen theatre. Dr. Chapin follows it into the theatre and tension builds up towards the climactic ass-buzzing scream-fest – but what interests me are the final shots before the film is stopped and Vincent Price tells the whole audience to scream for their lives. What is it that really causes the audience to panic? Is it the electric seats? Is it the fear of the monster at your feet? Or is it what I would like to propose: the actual manifestation of the Blind Spot on your screen! To clarify: the last thing to happen before the film is interrupted is that the Tingler crawls into the projectionist’s booth, cuts the film apart and ultimately projects the silhouette of itself unto the screen. It is important to note that the image in the film is not that of a framed cinema screen with the silhouette on it, but rather the screen that we – the real audience – are watching becomes the same screen that the audience within the film are watching:[14]
The audience watching the film.
The film of the theatre expanded unto our screen.
And the tingler projecting itself unto our screen, into “both” theatres!
After this shot we see dr. Chapin and mr. Higgins (Philip Coolidge) standing by the audience, staring up at the screen. Then the screen goes black – and the screaming begins. The Blind Spot of our Bodies has made itself visible in our cinematic experience and rendered clear the role of the horror film – to show us what it’s like to have the Real within our world.
III
There is another element of Žižek’s article that is mirrored in an interesting way in The Tingler and that is the idea of the “silent scream”. Žižek arrives at a formula of the relationship between voice and image whereas voice points toward a gap in the field of the visible: “In other words, their relationship is mediated by an impossibility: ultimately, we hear things because we cannot see everything.”[15] But then Žižek reverses this logic in order to present “the image that renders present the failure of the voice – an image can emerge as the placeholder for a sound that doesn’t yet resonate but remains stuck in the throat.”[16] Citing Munch’s Scream, he comes up with the line that the article takes its name from – of hearing with one’s eyes. He cites Derrida and the idea that “hearing oneself speak” is the key element to experiencing oneself as a living being whereas “seeing onself looking” stands for one’s death (because the Blind Spot is included in our field of vision, like the Tingler on our screen). In this way gaze and voice relate to each other as life and death, whereas voice vivifes and gaze mortifies. Žižek connects this to the idea that in music we can hear what we can not see – namely, the vibrating life force, “the drive of the life substance that words can only signify” – and then poses an interesting question: “What happens [...] when this flux of life substance itself is suspended, discontinued?”[17]
It is no coincidence that the manifestation of the Blind Spot in The Tingler takes place in a silent movie theatre – and it is certainly no coincidence that the theatre owner is Martha Higgins (Judith Evelyn) – a deaf and dumb woman who not only suffers from blood trauma but can do nothing to release her fear: she can’t utter a sound and therefore she can’t scream.[18] When Dr. Chapin cuts his finger on a broken saucer she sees the blood and goes into total shock. Chapin comments that he has never seen anyone so terrified and so unable to release the fear tensions: “Her unreleased tensions grow so great that she goes into psychosomatic blackout.” Then dr. Chapin’s assistant poses another interesting question, quite similar to the one posed by Žižek: “What if she didn’t?”[19] In other words, what happens if her only means of repressing her fear – going into shock because she can’t scream – was suspended, discontinued?
At this point, an image emerges, an image that stands for absolute death[.] [...] For more horrifying than to see with our ears – to hear the vibrating life substance beyond visual representations [...] – is to hear with our eyes, that is, to see the absolute silence that marks the suspension of life.[20]
Žižek takes Caravaggio’s Testa di Medusa as an example of such an image, where the scream is by defination silent, “stuck in the throat”, and provides an image of “the moment at which the voice fails” – of absolute death.[21] I propose that the following image is another example of precisely this:[22]
A scream stuck in the throat – resulting in absolute death.
This scene – the hallucinations scene where Martha is literally scared to death – shows Martha waking up to a living nightmare. She is attacked by monsters and ultimately flees into the bathroom where she is confronted with a bathtub full of blood. Throughout the scene she tries to express her fear but she can’t – slowly growing weaker as her body buckles under the pressure – until finally the Tingler crushes her spine and she drops dead on the bathroom floor. The viewer knows that Martha can not scream but nevertheless anxiously awaits to hear the screaming – as we are used to hearing screams in scenes similar to this one. But of course it never arrives. All we can hear is silence – or rather, all we can see is silence – as we hear Martha’s silent screams with our eyes, marking the suspension of life, resulting in her inevitable and absolute death – which, interestingly enough, brings us to the Tingler’s birth as an independent life form. Before I head on to the second part of this essay I would like to throw one more idea into this Žižekian mixture.
If we consider voice functioning as the objet petit a of the visual, as Žižek proposes, we can add yet another dimension to the metaphor of the Tingler as symbolic of the Blind Spot, as it originates in Martha’s voice – or rather, the lack of Martha’s voice – and is therefore born out of sound. The Tingler not only becomes symbolic of the uncertain or unnameable Real that surrounds us, but of the Blind Spot as a Voice. And when the Tingler projects itself on-screen it is in fact the Voice thrusting itself into the Image, thereby destroying the symbolic order and bridging the unbrideable gap that separates the human body – the image – from the voice:
[T]he screen image becomes a delusive surface, a lure secretly dominated by the bodiless voice of an invisible/absent Master, a voice that cannot be attached to any object in the diegetic reality[.] […] What we have to renounce is thus the commonsense notion of a primordial, fully constitued reality in which sight and sound complement each other: the moment we enter the symbolic order, an unbridgeable gap separates forever a human body from “its” voice.[23]
In other words, not only does its horror of the Tingler lie in the visual manifestation of the Real inside our world, but it can make Žižek’s “invisible master” become visible – the master who will play an important role as an absent and disembodied voice in the second half of this essay.
Part Two: The Attack Of The Expanded BrainScreens
I
Expanded cinema”, i.e. the expansion of the commonplace form of film on the open stage or within a space, through which the commercial-conventional sequence of filmmaking – shooting, editing (montage), and projection – is broken up, was the art-form that I chose in the mid-1960s[.] [..] Today, expanded cinema is the electronic, digital cinema, the simulation of space and time, the simulation of reality. […] “Expanded cinema” also refers to any attempts that activate, in addition to sight and hearing, the senses of smell, taste, and touch.[24]
-Valie Export
Without delving too deep into the idea of “expanded cinema”, I find it interesting to think of William Castle’s cinematic experiments in relation to the experimental cinema of the Viennese actionists in the 1960s, including the work of Valie Export, and the idea of working with the boundaries between the cinematic apparatus and the spectator, of extending (or expanding) the screen to include senses of actual touch, smell or taste – of making the metaphors literal. Even though the philosophy behind the work of Export and Castle is very different they have a lot in common nevertheless. Castle’s reason for expanding the audience’s perception of his films was simply made for entertainment purposes – to give the audience a scare by making them experience something unexpected and new. Valie Export worked from a feminist perspective and her work is more political – the whole background is in fact radically different – where the film phenomenon is “split up into its formal components, and then put back together again in a new way” and the “filmic artwork was no longer understood only in its symbolic expression, but replaced by signs of the real; the media-technical separation of image and sound was transformed into reality.”[25]
William Castle had many ways of breaking down the cinematic illusion for his viewers and in fact the idea of activating the viewer’s different senses – even the viewer himself – incorporated a big part of the experience of going to see a William Castle production – it was a different way to experience cinema. A number of his tricks involved experimenting with the body, i.e. the special “Illusion-o Ghost Viewer” glasses (13 Ghosts, 1960) and seat belts for the frightened (I Saw What You Did, 1965), and others involved the viewer’s awareness as a viewer, i.e. the “Fright Break” during Homicidal (1961) that allowed cowards to flee the cinema, and even audience participation in the “Punishment Poll” where viewers were given the opportunity of voting for the killing or the sparing of the villain in Mr. Sardonicus (1961). The Tingler experiments with tactile sensations when the seats become electrified but also has another gimmick that was not performed at every cinema (due to extra costs) and is also an experiment within cinematic space reminiscent of the “expanded cinema” of the 1960s in Europe. Just before the film is stopped to make way for the electric seats, there is another “break” in the film after a woman in the audience on-screen starts screaming at the sight of the Tingler by her feet. When that scene was played at certain cinemas back in the day some actors were employed to play out a performance of carrying a fainted woman out of the audience. These examples are very literal ways of explaining the extension of the cinematic experience and breaking the boundaries between the viewing distance of the spectator and the screen. But there is another element to the two scenes in The Tingler where the actual film is stopped.
During the first of the two scenes dr. Chapin and mr. Higgins enter the cinema and see the woman screaming. When this happens dr. Chapin pushes a switch on the wall and cuts off electric power in the theatre. It becomes completely dark and his voice addresses the audience: “Ladies and gentlemen, there’s no cause for alarm. A young lady has fainted. She is being attended to by a doctor, and is quite alright. […] The movie will begin again right away.”[26] This was the cue for the actors to carry out their performance in the theatre. Then dr. Chapin turns the power back on, the light (vision) returns and the film continues. It is important to note that this scene is radically different from the one that is to follow – the scream-fest – because the fact that dr. Chapin actually turns off the power implies that his character is only addressing the on-screen audience. There is visible action inside the film that makes the place go dark – the turning of the switch – whereas the second time it happens there is nothing to indicate that anyone has switched off any lights. This difference between the two scenes is indicative of how the film uses narrative elements in order to expand into the actual real life audience – as opposed to the more simple way of electric seats and theatrical actors:[27]
Dr. Chapin turns off the power . . .
. . . addresses the audience . . .
. . . and turns the lights back on, thus resuming the visual narrative of the film.
By contrast, when the Tingler has projected itself on the cinema screen and “attacked” the feature film, these are the images that frame the darkness of the interrupted film:[28]
Dr. Chapin and Mr. Higgins looking at the screen.
Vincent Price’s voice narrating over a black screen.
Dr. Chapin and Mr. Higgins still looking at the screen.
They are as defenseless as the rest of the audience, staring at the Tingler’s projectioned image on the cinema screen (staring at the Blind Spot). So who is addressing the audience, and which audience is he addressing? The voice comes from outside of the cinematic space – it is not dr. Chapin who is speaking, but a disembodied voice without a diegetic source – the beforementioned “invisible master”. It could just as well be the voice of Vincent Price, addressing the audience from outside the visual frame of the film, because there is nothing in the diegetic reality of the visual element to establish that dr. Chapin is the one speaking – unlike the former shot where he actually turns off the lights.
The difference between the two shots is crucial in a discussion of the expansion of William Castle’s film. In the former scene, although both audiences may think that the voice is speaking to them, the diegetic source reveals dr. Chapin as the speaker – and his dialogue is aimed directly at the on-screen audience (and only indirectly at the actual audience). This is interesting in relation to the fact that the performance with the fainted woman is not as well known as the electric seats and was not performed in most theatres. In the second scene the disembodied voice of Vincent Price does not address the on-screen audience at all – but is solely directed at the actual viewers. During this scene the audience are made a part of the cinematic experience as the actual mainstream narrative is put on hold – the illusion of visual representation is broken as we can only see a black screen – and for around forty seconds the cinematic experience becomes something else altogether.
II
The brain is unity. The brain is the screen. I don’t believe that linguistics and psychoanalysis offer a great deal to the cinema. On the contrary, the biology of the brain – molecular biology – does.[29]
– Gilles Deleuze
In her article, “The Universe as Metacinema”, Patricia Pisters opens with a quote from Alfred Hitchcock about the direct influence – and manipulation – of a viewer’s brain: a metaphor of the audience as a giant organ to be played. She goes on to compare different readings of Hitchcock’s universe through the writing of Žižek and Deleuze and connects Hitchcock’s idea of the brain-organ to the rhizomatic model of thinking, where the brain literally becomes the screen:
According to Deleuze, the brain, which is both an intellectual and an emotional entity and functions parallel (not hierarchically) to the body, can give more insight about how we perceive ourselves as subject. So for Deleuze, Hitchcock’s remark about the electrodes in the brain is not symptomatic in leaving out the most important thing; rather, it is a philosophic reflection about how images work and about the direct effects of images in themselves.[30]
When we think about the interplay between body and brain in a way where vision has lost its hierarchical status and is parallel to the bodily experience, once again we end up with a literal metaphor when viewing Castle’s film. Looking at the catalog of Castle films it is possible to say that he attempts to play his viewers like an organ – even though it is not done through electrodes in the brain, but rather through electric shocks in the behind.
Let’s go back to the beginning of this essay for a moment. We are sitting in one of many cinemas in the United States watching The Tingler when suddenly the movie is stopped. Everything goes black. We hear a voice addressing us, speaking from outside of the virtual space of the film – speaking directly to us, the actual viewers. It tells us to scream because we are being attacked. We feel bodily sensations as we are given electric shocks and we hear everyone around us screaming. We scream. The voice tells us that everything is okay and the film starts again. We keep watching the film. And we are left to wonder: what the hell just happened? Did we just enter the cinematic space or did the film enter our bodily space? Did the whole theatre just become a huge brain?! And if so, did we become electrodes inside this cinematic brain, being played like the notes of an organ?
It is an important factor that there are no visual elements at all during this scene. It emphasizes the idea of the visual as losing its hierarchical status – and rather focuses on the bodily experience of “watching” a film. It is true that we can still experience audio but as I have already pointed out that particular aural representation does not derive from the actual film but from outside of its diegetic world. The viewer is experiencing a total breakdown of the feature film narrative – what I would like to dub as “the Attack” of the idea of expanded cinema, even before the actual concept was established in Europe in the mid-1960s.[31] The infamous “scream!” scene focuses completely on the spectator’s body as its target by removing the more traditional elements of visual and aural representation and in a way overwhelming the corporeal realm of the audience, making each member not only aware of their status as spectators but also participants in the cinematic experience as they follow William Castle’s advice and let rip with all they’ve got.
III
There’s gonna be room in their [the audience’s] heads for only one thought: “Don’t let it get me.” They know we can’t hurt’em – but they’re still gonna be scared half to death. [...] And just when it gets the worst – when they’re sitting there and their hearts are going like little trapped animals out here in the dark – we save them! And they say: “Hey, it’s alright! Thank God!”[32]
- Lawrence Woolsey, in his motivational speech before the premiere of Mant
The above quote is taken from Joe Dante’s Matinee (1993), starring John Goodman as Lawrence Woolsey – a character based on William Castle, who is premiering his new feature film, Mant, with gimmicks such as “Atom-o Vision” – “the new motion picture miracle that puts you in the action”[33] – and “Rumble-Rama”. The film is an interesting examination of the cinematic experience of actually seeing a William Castle film in the early 1960s as the second half of Matinee exclusively takes place during the screening of Mant. But going into an examination of Matinee would take up another essay in itself, so I shall only touch on a single subject as a finale to this one.
It is the idea of safety that Woolsey comments upon in the above quote. In another scene he comments that the viewer who covers his eyes during frightening scenes of a horror film is not getting the full benefit of the experience – which is the cathartic idea of the audience being “saved” at the end of the film (which, coincidentally, becomes very literal in the final scene of Matinee). In Woolsey’s opinion, we go to the cinema so that we can better enjoy life – or rather, we can enjoy the illusion of safety when we exit the cinema still in one piece (even though our asses may have been buzzed and the screen may have attacked our bodies in more than one way). I am reminded of Thomas Elsaesser’s definition of classical cinema and post-classical cinema in our lecture notes as the former being “safe however close you get” and the second as “unsafe at any distance”.[34] It seems to me that Castle’s experimental films such as The Tingler are situated right at the boundaries between the two – that these literal manifestations of metaphors are tremors from a changing cinematic experience. What happens to the viewer when the safe visual distance is no longer there? What happens when we think of the ability of a film to stretch out into the audience, to touch and feel out its audience, and manipulate them in a two-way process – where the viewer is no longer subjectively looking at an image but participating in a constant formation of meaning and perception? This is precisely what happens when The Tingler stops and the screaming begins. But then we “resume the showing of the movie” and the audience is “saved” as we enter back into the traditional visual narrative (“Thank God!”)
Outroduction – Is The Tingler Still Loose In This Theatre?
I’ve been to revivals of Castle’s films and it’s a lot of fun, but it’s not the same experience because you can’t capture the same cultural moment and I think it’s mostly film fans who are looking back with nostalgia at a much simpler kind of time.[35]
- David Skal, film historian
In the above quote taken from the documentary Scream For Your Lives! film historian David Skal ponders the idea of experiencing a William Castle feature in contemporary film society, believing that his films are indeed a part of a past long gone and can only be viewed with nostalgic regret. That much is probably true – but neverthelss I would like to propose that Castle’s films can spark an amalgam of interesting writing in film studies and need to be re-evaluated in terms of different ideas that have been evolving for the last fifty years or so. His films have not had a lot of attention from film scholars through the years and not much has been written on the subject of his eccentric cinema. This could have something to do with the fact that Castle’s films are usually classified as kitchy b-movies that are only meant to be experienced as pure entertainment – a point of view that Castle himself would be proud to accept, no doubt. But it is of special importance to rethink William Castle’s status within the study of film theory. There is so much more to Castle’s films – ideas that are possibly only coming to light now because of contemporary questions regarding electronic and digital media and of reality simulation through virtual technology (some of Castle’s gimmicks could well be read as early examples or even predecessors of contemporary virtual reality). Even though his films were not connected to the theoretical practice of film studies, unlike the work of Valie Export and the Viennese actionists for example, his films are like a mainstream mirror of many of the ideas surrounding the experimental cinema of the 1960s regarding physical performances, viewer awareness, different perceptive senses and the breaking up of the traditional experience of the cinematic apparatus – the greatest difference being that Castle’s films posed these questions to a wide range of mainstream audiences.
So let me set the scene for you once again. It is the fall of 2005 and we are sitting in a cinema watching an old William Castle feature. We understand that this film used to have gimmicks but since modern day cinemas don’t care much for that sort of stuff we are not really expecting anything out of the ordinary to happen. So we look past the literal surface of bodily attacks and theatrical performances and wonder what lies beneath the entertaining facade of electric seats, flying skeletons and “Illusion-o” glasses. I have pointed out a few of the things that lie in waiting for those courageous enough to face them – bodily blind spots, silent screamers and expanded brainscreens – but there is much more to be explored from this Master of Entertainment whose bold experiments and unconventional mainstream filmmaking deserve closer inspection. But not in a nostalgic or tragic lamentation for “a much simpler kind of time” – enough has been written about that aspect of his films – but rather through a modern connection with contemporary cinema and film theory, looking towards a future of virtual reality and expanded bodily experiences in order to better understand the whole experience of “watching” a William Castle presentation.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Apsel, Joyce, “Anne’s words still strengthen spirits.” St. Petersburg Times Online, January 26, 2000. Website [last viewed 31.10.2005]: http://www.sptimes.com/News/012600/NIE/Anne_s_words_still_st.shtml
Castle, William, Step Right Up! I’m Gonna Scare the Pants Off America. First Pharos Edition. New York, Pharos Books, 1992.
Deleuze, Gilles, “The Brain Is the Screen. An Interview with Gilles Deleuze.” Translator: Marie Therese Guirgis. The Brain Is the Screen. Deleuze and the Philosophy of Cinema. Editor: Gregory Flaxman. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 2000, pp. 365-373.
Elsaesser, Thomas, “Film Theory I & II: Body, Senses and the Moving Image”. Lecture notes, 14.09.2005. Website [last viewed 31.10.2005]: http://blackboard.ic.uva.nl/@@db4d4d8f327bf3eeb476513d3c042d01/courses/1/10.OMSA.PP81131.1A.20052006/content/_425295_1/Lecture_TE_2_Doors_and_Screens.doc
Export, Valie, “Expanded Cinema as Expanded Reality.” Senses of Cinema, Issue No. 28, Sept-Oct 2003. Website [last viewed 31.10.2005]: http://www.sensesofcinema.com/contents/03/28/expanded_cinema.html
Matinee. Director: Joe Dante. Universal Pictures, 1993 [DVD version, Pathé Distribution, 2003].
Pisters, Patricia, “The Universe as Metacinema.” The Matrix of Visual Culture: Working with Deleuze in Film Theory. [Palo Alto], Stanford University Press, 2003, pp. 14-44.
Roosevelt, Franklin D., “First Inaugural Address.” Bartleby.com. Inaugural Addresses of the Presidents of the United States. Website [last viewed 31.10.2005]: http://www.bartleby.com/124/pres49.html
Scream For Your Lives! William Castle and “The Tingler”. Director: Jeffrey Schwarz. Columbia Tristar Home Video, 1999.
The Brain Is the Screen. Deleuze and the Philosophy of Cinema. Editor: Gregory Flaxman. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 2000.
The Tingler. Director: William Castle. William Castle Productions, 1959 [DVD version, Columbia Pictures, 1999].
Žižek, Slavoj, “‘I Hear You With My Eyes’; or, The Invisible Master.” Gaze and Voice as Love Objects. Editors: Slavoj Žižek and R. Salecl. Durham, Duke University Press, 1996, pp. 10-103.
[1] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 1: “Start.”
[2] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 2: “Immediate autopsy.”
[3] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 1: “Start.”
[4] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 26: “Scream!”
[5] Castle, William, Step Right Up! I’m Gonna Scare the Pants Off America, pp. 153.
[6] Primo Levi quote taken from Apsel, Joyce, “Anne’s words still strengthen spirits.” [Website]
[7] Žižek, Slavoj, “‘I Hear You With My Eyes’; or, The Invisible Master,” pp. 90.
[8] Žižek, Slavoj, “‘I Hear You With My Eyes’; or, The Invisible Master,” pp. 90-91.
[9] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 22: “A dangerous thing.”
[10] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 9: “See anything unusual?”
All images taken from The Tingler DVD version, Columbia Pictures, 1999.
[11] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 19: “Drinks with Isabel.”
[12] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 22: “A dangerous thing.”
[13] One is reminded of Franklin D. Roosevelt’s famous line: “The only thing we have to fear is fear itself.” Roosevelt, Franklin D., “First Inaugural Address.”
[14] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 25: “TOL’ABLE DAVID” and Chapter 26: “Scream!”
[15] Žižek, Slavoj, “‘I Hear You With My Eyes’; or, The Invisible Master,” pp. 93.
[16] Žižek, Slavoj, “‘I Hear You With My Eyes’; or, The Invisible Master,” pp. 93.
[17] Žižek, Slavoj, “‘I Hear You With My Eyes’; or, The Invisible Master,” pp. 94.
[18] The idea of the silent scream is made evident in the opening sequence of the film (from which a still can be seen on the cover of this essay) where a composed shot of people screaming fades into the image of a man so frightened that he is unable to scream as he is awaiting his death in the electric chair. The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 1: “Start.”
[19] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 6: “David.”
[20] Žižek, Slavoj, “‘I Hear You With My Eyes’; or, The Invisible Master,” pp. 94.
[21] Žižek, Slavoj, “‘I Hear You With My Eyes’; or, The Invisible Master,” pp. 94.
[22] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 14: “Martha hallucinates.”
[23] Žižek, Slavoj, “‘I Hear You With My Eyes’; or, The Invisible Master,” pp. 92.
[24] Export, Valie, “Expanded Cinema as Expanded Reality.”
[25] Export, Valie, “Expanded Cinema as Expanded Reality.”
[26] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 25: “TOL’ABLE DAVID.”
[27] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 25: “TOL’ABLE DAVID.”
[28] The Tingler. Director: William Castle, Chapter 26: “Scream!”
[29] Deleuze, Gilles, “The Brain Is the Screen. An Interview with Gilles Deleuze,” pp. 366.
[30] Pisters, Patricia, “The Universe as Metacinema,” pp. 17-18.
[31] Export, Valie, “Expanded Cinema as Expanded Reality.”
[32] Matinee. Director: Joe Dante, Chapter 8.
[33] Matinee. Director: Joe Dante, Chapter 1.
[34] Elsaesser, Thomas, “Film Theory I & II: Body, Senses and the Moving Image”.
[35] Scream For Your Lives! William Castle and “The Tingler”. Director: Jeffrey Schwarz.











