Painting With Film
affective immediacy and temporal narrative in the cinema of David Lynch
Part I - Moving Paintings
Once upon a time David Lynch looked at one of his paintings – an almost all-black painting of a garden – when he suddenly heard the wind blowing. For a second he saw the painting move and got the idea of making a moving painting with accompanying sound. In 1967 he produced his first moving painting – Six Men Getting Sick (Six Times) – a minute long animated loop showing six figures vomiting, looped six times. Originally presented on a sculptured canvas, this painting would later become known as David Lynch’s first short film.
He made the painting for an experimental painting and sculpture contest at his school and consequently won first prize. One H. Barton Wasserman saw the piece of work, liked it, and commissioned another of the sort to be made by Lynch for his private collection. Lynch got some money, bought his first camera and after one failed experiment he finally produced his second moving painting, The Alphabet (1968), with funding from Wasserman. The painting incorporated real-life acting mixed together with animated sequences and told the story of a young girl’s nightmare about the letters of the alphabet. Generally referred to as Lynch’s second short film, The Alphabet strays further from the path of painting towards a more general narrative. This would become more clear in Lynch’s next “short film”, The Grandmother (1970), which is the longest of his shorts (around thirty-four minutes long). Even though it has animated parts the film generally revolves around real-life actors and set pieces, focusing on a young boy and his un-loving parents. Out of loneliness he grows a grandmother from a seed in his room in search of friendship in a cold dark world. The Grandmother is in many ways a precursor to 1977’s Eraserhead, and although neither one are best remembered for their narrative elements – the films stray far off the beaten path of classical Hollywood narrative and hold up mostly because of style and atmosphere – when compared to his earlier shorts it remains obvious that Lynch has come a long way from his original projections on canvas and into the world of cinema – a step that became finally clear with his first studio production, The Elephant Man, in 1980.
Lynch was not trained as a filmmaker, but as a painter at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts. In addition to painting and film he has participated in numerous other art projects in recent years, including writing, photography, animation, music, sculpting and printmaking, all of which would be interesting subjects of research – but I am only focusing on his career as a filmmaker and painter. What had originally been combined in his early shorts – or moving paintings – has become seperated into two different mediums. As his film career progressed he never gave up painting on the side, although most people know him because of his filmic work rather than his paintings. In this short essay I intend to elaborate briefly on certain elements that cause this seperation – and try to connect them back together in search of further understanding on how the films of David Lynch should be examined. By using a concrete example of a filmmaker like Lynch I hope to bring to light some basic assumptions about the relationship between the art of painting and the art of film in the process.
Still images from Six Men Getting Sick (Six Times) (1967) and The Alphabet (1968).
Part II - Temporal Dimensions
Edward Hopper is another guy I love, but more for cinema than for painting. Instantly, when you see those works, you dream.
- David Lynch[1]
One of the main differences between a painting and a piece of film is the illusion of movement. Even though both mediums can employ this illusion it is not as self-evident in the case of film as it is with painting – it is only through human perception that the twenty-four still frames of each second of a film sequence can be translated as actual motion. Through this illusion comes the element of time – the temporal dimension of a moving picture, be it a self-evident still image of a painting or the perceptual illusion of film. When looking at a traditional film and comparing it to a traditional painting the major differentiating element seems to be the length – a film might go on for an hour and a half while the painting sits still within its own frame of reference. It might be argued that there are other differentiating elements, such as sound and “motion”, but I will bypass these in order to stay true to David Lynch’s original ideas of a moving painting, thus widening the traditional understanding of painting to include both sound and “motion”. I would rather focus on the fact that through length and time – through the stretching out of action – comes the essential structure for narrative development.
As a representative of the temporal dimension in painting I would like to discuss briefly the work of Edward Hopper, where the element of time is a key feature. Hopper is one of Lynch’s two all time favorite painters – the other one being Francis Bacon – and I would like to juxtapose the two artists as being symbolic for two different sides of the relationship between film and painting, where Hopper stands for the dimension of time – how a painting can become cinematic and how a film becomes narrative – and Bacon for the plane of immediacy – how a dissolution of narrative can bring a film to a plane normally reserved for painting.
Hopper’s work is generally regarded as being highly cinematic and even though he never directly worked on any films his connection to the world of cinema is well known. He has been influential on various filmmakers through the years, the most famous examples being on post-war film noir, Alfred Hitchcock (the Bates motel in Psycho (1960) was based on a Hopper painting) and numerous Wim Wenders films. The cinematic quality of Hopper’s work has been neatly defined by Wenders who believes that each painting can be expanded into imaginary sequences because the viewer imagines a “before” and “after” to each still scene, thereby implying not only movement but also an added temporal dimension to the painting’s setting. In his article, “Two or Three Things I Know About Edward Hopper”, Peter Wollen writes that
Hopper’s tableaux thus contain a temporal dimension which, in each viewer’s mind, could be vitalised and set in motion. [...] His paintings of buildings are like still photographs, mostly uninhabited. Looking at these buildings the viewer inevitably begins to wonder who is living in the house, to hypothesise about who might have left and who might be arriving. Perhaps Wim Wenders was right to suggest that Hopper’s paintings invite us to imagine a “before” and an “after”, to speculate on who inhabits the buildings, what goes on inside them, but also what has happened in them in the past and what might occur in the future.[2
If we can assume that through the temporal dimension the illusion of narrative is born in the example of Edward Hopper – what has been referred to as the “cinematic” quality to his work – then it can be argued that therein lies a seperation – or overlap – between the medium of painting and film. With the introduction of narrative the temporal dimension is expanded to include outside elements. The viewer does not experience the work in isolation but as part of a narrative space that surrounds it. In this way a painting can be said to become cinematic – it moves beyond its own frame to refer to imaginary settings, to imaginary times – or as David Lynch puts it: “Instantly, when you see those works, you dream.”[3]
Photograph by Donata Wenders from the set of Wim Wenders’ The End of Violence (1997) and Edward Hopper’s Nighthawks (1942).
Part III - Narrative Dissolutions
Rodley: Bacon’s paintings often imply a narrative, but it’s unclear excactly what is going on. Does that interest you?
Lynch: Exactly right. Fragments of narrative.
If Bacon had made a movie, what would it have been and where would it have gone ? And how would the cinema translate those textures and those spaces ?
Lynch on Lynch[4]
If it is through narrative that a seperation takes place between a film and a painting it is through the dissolution – or even utter destruction – of narrative that painting and film can be reunited. To paraphrase, if the difference between painting and film lies within the temporal dimension it is on the plane of immediacy where the roles can be reversed and film can take on the quality of a painting, not vice versa. This can be argued in the case of David Lynch through a reading of his other favorite painter, Francis Bacon.
To clarify what I mean by a plane of immediacy I will refer to the work of cultural theorist dr. Greg Hainge, who has written on the relationship between David Lynch (using
having undergone this process, the Figure releases centrifugal forces as it attempts to escape itself through its very organs in a spasmodic movement so as to fade into the background, the very materiality of the painting. The effect of this, of course, is to further the narrative dissolution and thus intensify the pure immanence of the painting which is thus able to bypass the reflective mechanisms of mind and intellect to act directly on the spectator’s emotive core on a plane of immediacy.[5]
This idea is the focal point of Hainge’s article, “Weird or Loopy? Specular Spaces, Feedback and Artifice in Lost Highway’s Aesthetics of Sensation”, where he argues that in Lost Highway David Lynch is breaking the narrative convention in a way similar to Deleuze’s writing on the “Figural Process” in the work of Francis Bacon. Through the dissolution of narrative structure the immanence of the cinematic image becomes central and the temporal dimension becomes secondary. In this case the temporal dimension is the narrative structure that needs elements of time and longevity to become affective through the mechanisms of mind and intellect. Instead the affect of the immediate image becomes primary and works as a direct art of sensation. The image breaks free of its surrounding narrative space – of the mechanisms of mind and intellect – and refers only to its isolated self in order to plunge straight into the spectator’s emotive core. Hainge argues that through this sort of filmic expression Lynch is employing a technique normally reserved for painting – thus creating a theoretical bridge between Lynch the filmmaker and Lynch the painter.
Francis Bacon’s Head IV (1949) and a Baconian still image from Lost Highway (1997).
Part IV - The Filmmaker and The Painter
In the beginning, painting and film were combined in the work of David Lynch. Somewhere along the way the two mediums became seperated – at least on the surface of things – and I believe that Hainge’s idea of immediacy is one way of discussing how structural remnants of painting still exist in Lynch’s filmic works. It is up for grabs for further discussion to examine how many cinematic qualities can be found in his paintings – but that shall not be done in the short span of this essay. Rather I would like to draw attention to the middle ground between the two opposites that I have already put forth – being the narrative ground (represented by Hopper and the temporal dimension) and the non-narrative ground (represented by Bacon and the plane of immediacy). This is where the cinema of David Lynch is situated and thus an area where any discussion of his films must take place.
When looking at his bulk of early work it is apparent how narrative slowly takes over the original painting and the need to tell a story is in constant dialogue with the need to produce immediate images. Lynch has himself stressed on many accounts the influence of practicing transcendental meditiation and emphasized the bypassing of the conscious intellect as a key element to experiencing his work. His films are often referred to by critics and viewers alike as being illegible and “weird” and it will be an odd day in film history when his films will be considered to be a part of mainstream cinema. This goes to show that his films can not be evaluated by traditional “Hollywood” standards. When looking at the filmic works of Lynch one must realize that he is working in a very gray area – in a strange and wonderful limbo between two traditional mediums – and that is the reason why audiences can have problems with their viewing pleasures. Even though the immediate image never fully takes over the narrative – not to the extent of his early shorts – it can become very confusing for a viewer to focus entirely on a narrative as a sort of life-preserver to hang on to, hoping for some kind of understanding or explanation. In fact, to fully understand the experience of watching a Lynchian film the aesthetics of painting and the affective immediacy of an art of sensation must be considered as key factors.
I am aware that I am now getting dangerously close to surrealist territory – in particular when thinking about Lynch’s tendency to bypass the conscious and blame everything on transcendental or subconscious imagery – and I will attempt to sidestep that area as best I can as I follow up with a discussion about David Lynch’s mode of production in his upcoming film, Inland Empire. Even though many parts of it sound reminiscent of free association, automatic painting or other elements generally seen as part of the surrealist tradition, I believe that in its essence this mode of film production has more to do with the solitary act of painting than traditional filmmaking, be it surrealist or otherwise. In an interview with Variety about his new film, posted on May 11, 2005, Lynch explains his newfound love with digital video:
"For me, there's no way back to film. I'm done with it," Lynch says. "I love abstraction. Film is a beautiful medium, but it's very slow and you don't get a chance to try a lot of different things. With DV, you get those chances. And in post-production, if you can think it, you can do it."[6]
He had begun working with digital video for his website, DavidLynch.Com, and admits to having fallen in love with the medium because of the freedom it allows and the different possibilities it affords, both during shooting and working in post-production. I believe that this brings a whole new dimension to my discussion of immediacy in Lynch’s work as it sounds to me that this is in fact not David Lynch the filmmaker speaking, but rather his painter alter ego. Without having seen the new film – without needing to see the film – I am basing my opinion only on the writings on its mode of production. Nevertheless, I am ready to argue that in the case of David Lynch and digital video the artist may have come full circle – theoretically speaking – and reduced his double life as an artist back to the single hybrid state of making a moving painting.
I hope to have already shown that there are definite connections to be found linking the structural and formal qualities of painting within the films of David Lynch – that despite the fact that he gave up making “literal” moving paintings a long time ago the concept still exists, though in a different way, within his particular cinematic style. Through the constant battle between narrative and “subconscious” imagery Lynch mixes up traditional boundaries and is able to bring a film to planes normally reserved for painting. But with the introduction of digital video there is another step taking place. It is interesting to note that Lynch speaks of freedom when referring to digital video – like he has been freed from the restrictions of using film (and the submerged painter alter ego can finally roam free within the realm of cinema!). Obviously, film is an expensive medium and when using it every shot must be carefully planned in order for it not to be wasted, but with digital video that is never a problem. This gives way to more space for improvisation and experimentation – the freedom that Lynch speaks so fondly of. He even goes so far as to mention the time it takes to reload the film in the camera as being disruptive to the process of shooting: “When you run out of film, you have to stop and reload, and during that time the heat sometimes goes off. But with this medium you can keep that heat, and it builds, and it’s beautiful to see.”[7]
With digital video Lynch never has to stop and reload – he can change things as he goes along (he was writing the film as he was shooting it) and with the added possibilites of post-production he can keep on experimenting. I propose to juxtapose this with an image of David Lynch the painter, working in his studio – with his big canvas and his paintbrush, working spontaneously and carefully adding in the details later. The digital camera can be seen as equal to the brush and through computer technology the canvas can be expanded and changed to the director’s liking throughout the whole creative process. There are numerous overlaps between the art of painting and the art of film and I believe to have touched upon some of them in this essay, albeit rather abruptly – there is obviously a lot more work to be done on the subject, in particular with the advancing new technologies of digital filmmaking. The elements of time and narrative and the elements of immediate imagery (at the cost of narrative) are examples of theoretical overlaps, regarding the structure and form of the different mediums. Alternatively, the examples of Lynch’s early moving paintings are very obvious and literal overlaps between cinema and painting (and even sculpture) and it can be argued that through the use of digital video another literal transformation is taking place – that we are entering a higher plane of painting with digital technology instead of brushes and paint to such an extent that it seems impossible to speak of “films” anymore – and “movies” suddenly becomes a better choice of words.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
DavidLynch.com. Website [last accessed: 03.02.2006]: http://www.davidlynch.com/. DavidLynch.com, 2005.
Dawtrey, Adam. “Lynch Invades an Empire. Digital Pic Details a Mystery”, Variety.com. Variety Magazine Online. Posted: Wed., May 11, 2005, 5:10pm PT. Website [last accessed: 03.02.2006]: http://www.variety.com/index.asp?layout=cannes2005&content=story&articleid=VR1117922566. Reed Business Information, 2006.
Hainge, Greg. “Weird or Loopy? Specular Spaces, Feedback and Artifice in Lost Highway’s Aesthetics of Sensation”, The Cinema of David Lynch. American Dreams, Nightmare Visions. Edited by Erica Sheen and Annette Davison. London, Wallflower Press, 2005, pp. 136-150.
Harrison, Martin. In Camera. Francis Bacon: Photography, Film and the Practice of Painting. [London], Thames & Hudson, 2005.
Lynch on Lynch. Revised Edition. Edited by Chris Rodley. London, Faber and Faber, 2005.
The Short Films of David Lynch. Directed by David Lynch. DVD version, DavidLynch.com, 2002.
Wollen, Peter. “Two or Three Things I Know About Edward Hopper”, Edward Hopper. Edited by Sheena Wagstaff. London, Tate Publishing, 2004, pp. 68-81.
[1] Lynch on Lynch. Revised Edition, p. 17.
[2] Wollen, Peter. “Two or Three Things I Know About Edward Hopper”, pp. 78-79.
[3] Lynch on Lynch. Revised Edition, p. 17.
[4] Lynch on Lynch. Revised Edition, p. 17.
[5] Hainge, Greg. “Weird or Loopy? Specular Spaces, Feedback and Artifice in Lost Highway’s Aesthetics of Sensation”, p. 141.
[6] Dawtrey, Adam. “Lynch Invades an Empire. Digital Pic Details a Mystery”. Website.
[7] Dawtrey, Adam. “Lynch Invades an Empire. Digital Pic Details a Mystery”. Website.







No comments:
Post a Comment